LGBTQ People and the 2024 election: “I do not really feel welcome right here.”

Lucian Holness woke as much as a frightening actuality on Nov. 6. Acute stress led to the combination of feelings that struck the transgender advertising supervisor as they realized President-elect Donald Trump — by no means a dependable ally to the LGBTQ group and an more and more hostile determine for transgender People — had received a second time period within the White Home. 

“I went into this election absolutely anticipating Trump to win,” stated Holness, who lives in New Jersey and started to medically transition in the course of the pandemic, an expertise they known as “liberating” and “superb” after a very long time spent “feeling like one thing was improper.”

Assuming Trump would take the presidency once more was a self-preservation tactic, Holness advised CBS Information however it didn’t essentially soften the blow.

“Perhaps I believed it could be a better race than it was. And simply seeing what number of states we have been dropping, the immense manner that we misplaced … that actually destroyed me,” Holness stated. “And for a number of days after I had no hope in humanity.”

After the election, commentators and analysts urged Trump’s decisive victory in opposition to Vice President Kamala Harris was broad proof of a thirst for financial change throughout the brilliant purple map of the nation. To win, he had punctured the Democratic “blue wall” and flipped all seven battleground states, with CBS Information exit polls indicating he had acquired help from extra of the citizens than ever.

LGBTQ voters have been among the many solely demographic teams that didn’t stray towards Trump once they solid ballots within the presidential contest this yr. Black girls additionally overwhelmingly backed Harris on the polls.

“Black voters and queer voters understood the project on this election, and our project was to defeat the nice risk to our security and freedom that Trump poses, in order that we will battle for what all of us have to be secure and free,” stated Melanie Willingham-Jaggers, the manager director of GLSEN, an LGBTQ advocacy group targeted on supporting and educating younger folks. Willingham-Jaggers identifies as nonbinary and queer. 

The LGBTQ group has traditionally voted Democrat however not like most different demographic traits this yr, LGBTQ help for the celebration’s presidential nominee rose considerably from 2020. CBS Information’ nationwide exit polls confirmed 86% of people that recognized as lesbian, homosexual, bisexual or transgender voted for Harris, whereas simply 13% voted for Trump. Echoing most Harris voters, a majority of LGBTQ  folks stated they feared what might occur throughout one other Trump presidency.

Folks within the LGBTQ group advised CBS Information they see the recurrence of Trumpism as a tangible affront to their primary human rights. The implications really feel notably pressing to transgender People, whom the president-elect and his associates categorically focused all through the marketing campaign.

“Sadly, these people are sadly misinformed,” stated Karoline Leavitt, a spokesperson for the Trump-Vance transition staff, in a press release to CBS Information. “President Trump campaigned on being a president for ALL People and can unify our nation by way of nice success.”

“I do not really feel welcome right here”

The Trump marketing campaign ran commercials attacking trans folks for months forward of Election Day, in a transfer that probably value not less than tens of tens of millions of {dollars}. Criticized for scapegoating, one TV advert bore a tagline interpreted as an try and sow division: “Kamala is for they/them. President Trump is for you.”

The advocacy group GLAAD counted 225 outlined assaults on the LGBTQ group by Trump throughout his first White Home time period and newest presidential marketing campaign, by way of coverage selections and rhetoric, which transgender People and others who’re LGBTQ advised CBS Information is damaging by itself. The Trevor Challenge noticed a 700% spike in disaster calls all through the day after the election, and analysis from the group discovered latest politics negatively impacted the well-being of 90% of LGBTQ younger folks, whereas anti-trans state laws within the final yr drove up suicide makes an attempt amongst transgender and nonbinary youth by as a lot as 72%.

“I do not really feel welcome right here,” stated Holness.

Though New Jersey is a sanctuary state for LGBTQ rights, and Gov. Phil Murphy final yr declared it a secure haven for transgender and nonbinary folks searching for gender-affirming care, Holness remains to be involved concerning the methods wherein a second Trump administration and Republican Congress might doubtlessly work to interrupt down that refuge.

“What folks assume being trans is, versus the precise expertise of being trans, are so vastly totally different. And if folks would simply take heed to us, I feel they’d be stunned how a lot we’re the identical as them,” Holness advised CBS Information. “It took me some time to take Trump significantly, however after seeing the rise in trans hate crimes, and the rise in anti-trans laws, the bounty out on trans folks only for present, you recognize, it is develop into actually scary.”

Trump’s anti-LGBTQ and particularly anti-trans positions stretch again to his first time period within the White Home, when he scrubbed federal company websites of illustration and proceeded to roll again protections for LGBTQ  folks, amongst different coverage selections that clamped down on their talents to stay and work freely.

However vitriol towards the group turned integral to Trump’s politics and his general public model in the course of the newest presidential bid. 

Well being care entry below siege

As Trump doubled down on anti-trans rhetoric in his speeches, he backed conservative proposals to limit entry to healthcare for transgender folks and punish medical doctors who give minors gender-affirming care. 

“The primary subject, of the numerous that the trans folks I spoke with are anxious about, is entry to the well being care that we have to stay. This isn’t an abstraction. It’s not a tradition battle. It’s not a political soccer,” stated Gillian Brandstetter, a communications strategist on the American Civil Liberties Union. “It is rather a lot an issue of fabric want. Can we entry hormone remedy? Can we keep our relationship with our medical doctors? Can we keep our insurance coverage protection?”

Trump pushed throughout his final administration to federally redefine gender alongside binary traces that will exclude transgender identities, successfully denying trans folks authorized recognition and upholding an outdated characterization of “organic intercourse,” regardless that the medical discipline has expanded its view of the spectrum of gender id. Renewed guarantees made by the marketing campaign this yr are fueling panic that he’ll try and implement it nationally once more.

Ryan Lyman, a trans faculty scholar in New York Metropolis who volunteered for the Harris marketing campaign and stated he has “passing privilege” after starting hormone remedy at 17 and present process high surgical procedure, advised CBS Information trans folks elsewhere within the nation are getting ready for the worst case situation. “Passing privilege” on this occasion means Lyman might keep away from a number of the prejudice different transgender folks face if he’s publicly perceived to be a cisgender man.

“I’ve seen lots of people on the Web recently who’re going again to their assigned gender presentation,” Lyman stated. “There is part of the group that lives within the Deep South, in purple states, who must go stealth for their very own security. And I don’t decide them in any respect.”

A choice that might doubtlessly work to guard sure trans rights earlier than Inauguration Day is the end result of United States v. Skrmetti, a landmark case set to go earlier than the Supreme Court docket in December the place justices will hear a problem to Tennessee’s ban on gender-affirming well being take care of transgender folks youthful than 18. The choice might have wide-ranging impacts at a time the place nearly half of U.S. states have enacted legal guidelines to restrict entry to numerous points of gender-affirming care, like hormones, puberty-blocking medication or surgical procedure.

An unsure future

Many LGBTQ persons are anxious about how Trump might alter basic components of their lives, out on the planet and at dwelling.

A rising variety of transgender social media customers have now spent the higher a part of a month sharing steerage on the way to replace licenses, passports and different authorized paperwork to mirror their names and pronouns. LGBTQ {couples} advised CBS Information they’re having conversations about whether or not they need to rush to get married earlier than January’s inauguration and what household planning may seem like as soon as Trump is sworn in.

Lee Robinson, a comic transferring from Denver to New York Metropolis, stated they have been already contemplating a few of these massive questions inside days of the election. That they had began to debate their choices with their girlfriend, too.

“It is not simply marriage, it is parentage and fertility stuff, and queer adoption,” stated Robinson. “It simply completely throws off our skill to plan for our futures when this type of factor occurs.”

Everybody who spoke to CBS Information for this story shared considerations about dropping discrimination protections below a second Trump administration. Additionally they surprise what it could imply if the Supreme Court docket’s 2015 marriage equality ruling got here below evaluate and marriage rights, like abortion rights, have been returned to the states.

An up to date coverage rundown on Trump’s 2024 marketing campaign web site known as Agenda 47 presents a blueprint of his “20 Core Guarantees To Make America Nice Once more.” Among the many objects on that checklist, Trump pledges to “hold males out of ladies’s sports activities” and minimize federal funding for faculties “pushing vital race principle, radical gender ideology, and different inappropriate racial, sexual, or political content material on our youngsters.” 

This stuff echo GOP state lawmakers and authorities leaders who’ve sought to bar trans youth from athletic groups that align with their gender identities and ban LGBTQ and racial identity-focused lesson plans and books from faculty curriculum. The First Modification’s freedom of speech and faith clauses have been utilized in high-profile courtroom circumstances to justify anti-LGBTQ discrimination.

They aren’t simply ideas. Anti-LGBTQ doctrines embraced at Republican rallies have lately been codified throughout the nation, retaining transgender youngsters off of sports activities groups and away from loos aligned with their gender id. In Florida, legal guidelines have been handed to take transgender-focused curriculum out of faculties; a authorized settlement earlier this yr clarified that college students and lecturers would be capable to focus on gender id so long as it is not a part of the curriculum. 

Capitol Hill is just not immune, as Rep.-elect Sarah McBride, a Delaware Democrat set to develop into the primary overtly transgender individual in Congress, confronted a swift Republican-led try after her trailblazing win to limit her restroom use within the Capitol Complicated.

“It is dehumanizing folks,” stated Sarah Kate Ellis, the president and CEO of the advocacy group GLAAD. “They need to deal with us as second-class residents, query our dignity and respect.”

Ellis stated measurable repercussions within the stability, like medical protection and equality below the legislation, are joined by intangible penalties that might trickle down generations.

“I consider my children, as my spouse and I’s marriage is below fireplace, however our neighbors’ marriage is not below fireplace. It is terrible when you consider that,” she shared. “So, my children, of their understanding, see us as lower than the household subsequent door as a result of they’ve two mothers versus a mother and a dad, or a single mother. I simply assume all these are their tradition wars, not ours.”

Challenge 2025

Consultants typically attribute the intensification of Trump’s anti-LGBTQ platform to his ties with right-wing non secular teams just like the Heritage Basis, a company with a protracted historical past of espousing anti-LGBTQ legal guidelines that helmed the presidential transition proposal Challenge 2025.

Challenge 2025 is a 900-page coverage handbook developed by a staff linked to greater than 100 conservative teams, to which Trump had denied connections, although he’s hiring a number of of its architects to fill key workers positions within the subsequent administration. The e-book requires an overhaul of the federal authorities to “restore household because the centerpiece of American life.” Its socio-political imaginative and prescient for a way to do this, launched on the primary web page of Challenge 2025, directs authorities officers to reject transgender folks and LGBTQ identities throughout the board.

“The subsequent conservative President should make the establishments of American civil society onerous targets for woke tradition warriors. This begins with deleting the phrases sexual orientation and gender id (“SOGI”), variety, fairness, and inclusion (“DEI”), gender, gender equality, gender fairness, gender consciousness, gender-sensitive, abortion, reproductive well being, reproductive rights, and another time period used to deprive People of their First Modification rights out of each federal rule, company regulation, contract, grant, regulation, and piece of laws that exists,” the doc states, on the outset of its opening chapter.

Though Trump tried to distance himself from Challenge 2025 on the marketing campaign path, even going as far as to name a few of its proposals “abysmal,” the blueprint is suitable with the Republican Occasion agenda. However on the similar time, Trump additionally plans to appoint Scott Bessent to be treasury secretary. He is a billionaire and former George Soros hedge fund supervisor and if confirmed, he’d be the primary overtly homosexual individual to serve on this function.

“We must always completely take Trump at his phrase,” stated Willingham-Jaggers, of GLSEN. “We must always take Challenge 2025 at its phrase. We must always count on a full courtroom press to get the whole lot outlined in Challenge 2025, created into coverage and enacted as the place to begin, not the top level, as the place to begin. That is half one. That is what I am involved about.”